My high school does a blackface skit reenacting domestic violence

Waverly, New York, the small town I grew up in, has received national media attention this week because of a skit performed by students during a pep rally last Friday. Two students dressed in blackface reenacted Chris Brown’s 2009 assault on his then-girlfriend Rihanna — to the tune of her hit, “Umbrella.” After a bit of Facebook rallying and email writing (and mostly some citizen reporting by a friend of mine), the story exploded on tumblr, Buzzfeed, the Associated Press, Crommunist, and eventually a proper report and write-up by CNN, including a few brief (and somewhat snarky) quotes by me:

Of Waverly’s 4,444 people, 4,312 were white, according to 2010 census data.

Chituc said he was “extraordinarily offended” by the skit and ashamed that his school seemed to be OK with it.

“On the one hand, I can’t blame the kids for being ignorant,” Chituc said. “It’s a small town, and the kids don’t know any better. It’s the responsibility of the administration to let the kids know this is not how you behave in 21st-century America. … They’ve been failing at that spectacularly.

The last I’ve heard is that no students had been punished for the skit, and I strongly suspect that no one would have even thought that something was wrong were it not for the national attention. But even if the blackface could legitimately be blamed on ignorance on the part of a small, white, and sheltered town, there’s no excuse for making a joke out of domestic violence. I got a response from the principal saying that “the format of the pep-rally will need to be reconsidered.” The format’s not the problem at all; rather, it’s a systemic failure on the part of the administration to teach students that racism and misogyny are not okay.

Mitt Romney has binders full of women

Though Mitt Romney’s comments at the debate last night quickly inspired jokes on tumblr and Twitter, Leah Libresco suggests on the Huffington Post that we’re too quick to judge what was actually a great move to support women.

There are a lot of things about Romney I don’t like, but what he did to address sexism was excellent, and I’m frustrated it’s being treated as a laugh line by other liberals. What he did was (sadly) pretty remarkable:

  1. Romney noticed they weren’t thinking of hiring women
  2. He assumed this indicated a problem with his team’s process instead of evidence that no qualified women existed
  3. He realized he and his team didn’t know how to find well-qualified women
  4. So he turned to womens’ groups for guidance
  5. And then he hired women!

Most organizations don’t make it very far past step one. They assume the dearth of qualified women is a fact about the world, not evidence of their own bias or problems in the pipeline. Even though, just this month, another study came out showing that men and women rate a sample resume as less qualified if there’s a woman’s name at the top of the page.

The Atlantic notes that it’s not quite as noble as Romney made it out to be, but good practice nonetheless.

The HPV vaccine doesn’t lead to risky behavior

A recent study in the journal Pediatrics showed that the HPV vaccine doesn’t encourage promiscuity. My reaction is split between, on one hand, being embarrassed that such a study even needed to be done (“Wait, we should stop. I don’t want to get HPV” whispered no teenager in the heat of the moment, ever), and on the other hand, thinking “so what if it had?”

I get that it might convince some concerned parents, but it’s sad that sexual purity is a larger concern than protecting our daughters from disease.

More from Jezebel: outing trolls to protect women

The personal information of Michael Brutsch, renowned Reddit creep who moderated the jailbait subreddit (a forum dedicated to posting sexualized photos of underaged girls), as well as the alleged identity of the sexual predator that drove 15 year-old Amanda Todd to suicide, have both been recently released by Gawker and Anonymous, respectively. Jezebel writes:

I agree with Doyle that “Knowing Michael Brutsch’s name is less important than knowing that we will challenge attitudes like his the next time we meet someone who expresses them.” But if people aren’t held accountable for their actions, men will continue to grope women on the subways, post creepshots, and bully teenage girls into flashing them — or worse. So let’s name names instead of continuing to accept this type of objectification as depressingly commonplace.

There’s a broader conversation to be had here about anonymity on the internet (the CEO of Reddit has come down sternly on the side of anonymity, refusing to ban any content so long as it is legal and doesn’t release personal information), but I’m just happy right now to see repercussions for people’s terrible behavior online.

Vlad Chituc is a lab manager and research assistant in a social neuroscience lab at Duke University. As an undergraduate at Yale, he was the president of the campus branch of the Secular Student Alliance, where he tried to be smarter about religion and drink PBR, only occasionally at the same time. He cares about morality and thinks philosophy is important. He is also someone that you can follow on twitter.

 

  • Random

    There are so many hypocrisies involving the Waverly pep rally I can’t begin to count them all.

    First of all it’s amazing how many former Waverly students have grown halos upon graduation. The social media scene has exploded with “outraged” Waverly alum. I can recall one Waverly grad who has expressed how “extraordinarily offended” he is by the pep rally who had to be taken aside and reprimanded during his time in Waverly High School for gay bashing. Many other former students took to Facebook to reflect on how ignorant all the Waverly bumpkins are, these same people would have been laughing along with everyone else if they had been in attendance. Oh the luxury of being an armchair philosopher.

    Everyone should take a moment to Google image the word “blackface.” Do some reading on it. It was used by white people to mock an entire RACE of people. The features of those in blackface were greatly exaggerated and extremely degrading. These students were mocking two SPECIFIC people who happen to be black and are also pop icons, and arrived with crappy spray on tans.

    They were not degrading an entire race of people by creating a skit based around stereotypes. They were mocking two specific pop icons and actions that ACTUALLY HAPPENED. Where were all the holier-than-thou finger pointers when Robert Downey Jr. donned blackface in Tropic Thunder? Where is all the Facebook hype when Dave Chapelle plays a blind “white supremacist?” When Chris Rock makes a racially charged joke at the Emmy Awards nobody bats an eye! But students mocking Christ Brown and Rihanna? BLASPHEMY.

    I’m curious how many people were posting their ever so important opinions of Waverly High School while listening to gangster rap glorifying domestic violence and dropping more racial slurs than anyone at Waverly has ever dreamed of using.

    My point is we are surrounded by worse things every day and nobody cares. Students perform a 30 second extremely tame skit and the internet is up in arms. Total hypocricy. Like THIS is the worst thing anyone has said about Chris Brown and Rihanna? This was SO EXTREME it required coverage by the Huffington Post? Give me a break. This one skit glorified domestic violence and racism more than any other Chris Brown and Rihanna related coverage?

    Yes, Waverly folk are so unbelievably ignorant, how could we possibly ever make such an awful mistake? Have you people ever listend to a Lil Wayne song? You can’t pick and choose your battles, if Waverly students are ignorant, wife beating racists then so are Lil Wayne, Chris Rock, Eminem, and most professional athletes. I want to see equal attention paid to them.